The Chocolate Life

Discover Chocolate and Live La Vida Cocoa!

I am wondering with all the new small bean to bar chocolate makers if any are getting heavy metal testing done. This I am curious about because some makers maybe get a bag or two in from obscure sources and heavy metal testing may not be something that they think they need to do. I know that Haigh's here in Adelaide are very concerned about this aspect and every shipment is evaluated for heavy metals. With their import size as well Australian customs would get on their case about the levels too but with smaller imports they may slip through - at least for a little while until customs catch on.

Is it common practice for plantations to have their soils tested or beans tested before export? I would guess no judging by the fact that Haigh's test everything. 

Also I do know that the Australian growers have their soils tested and this was a very important aspect of setting up the plantations.

Tags: heavy, metals

Views: 493

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

I do not know of a single grower that routinely does heavy metal testing.

Haigh's have to play by the rules.

In Australia (unlike in many other countries) there is maximum limit of 0.5ppm for Cadmium content in chocolate.

This means that beans from places like Ecuador or Venezuela (which have high Cadmium content) can be used only as a small part of total cocoa liquor in recipes.

Many exporters and brand owners will do heavy metals testing, but i've never met a grower who does.  S. and C. American soils are heavily volcanic, which in turn translates into the flesh of the bean.  Lead - which often is on the shell - is relatively easy to remove and mitigate.  Cadmium - which gets incorporated into the flesh to a higher degree than does lead - becomes more difficult to 'wash off', and blending strategies are employed if there are country specific regulations (Japan's another country with high hurdle regulations, for example)

So is the limit just a guide? Is Haighs only playing by the rules as a way to avoid customers laying any claims against them or is it an offence in itself to exceed the limit?

The limit is not just a guide.

Australian New Zealand Food Standard in Part 1.4.1 sets Maximum Level for heavy metal contaminants in food product and the maximum level for Cadmium in chocolate is 0.5mg/kg (not 0.5ppm as I have written above).

This is a legaly enforeable limit and applies to all chocolates sold in Australia and New Zealand.

As Sebastian correctly written above cocoa beans from some American countries have very high cadmium content which means that they can be used as a very limited percentage of your recipe.

no sir - rules are rules.  the question was do any plantation owners do heavy metals testing, and while there may be one out there, i've yet to meet him.  They normally don't have the technical capacity or competency to do so, and frankly it may not be in their best interest to do so even if they could.  The responsibility to ensure compliance with the finished product rests with the person offering the finished product, or the person importing the raw material.  larger exporters will conduct raw materials testing (pesticides, heavy metals, etc) for customers who are large enough to justify it - but again they're not going to do it for everyone as to be frank it creates a headache for them (a certain amount will fail - and then what?  now they've got a pile of rejected beans that they have to find a home for - the more they test the larger the pile is going to be..and frankly they're not selling chocolate, they're selling a component of it, and have no idea at which usage level (i.e. dilution rate) you're going to  use it, so they have no idea what level is appropriate for your usage rate..)

i am a cocoa farmer from east africa, and i am able to supply any quantity of cocoa bean requested  Contact me soonest if interested  lopezmariam3@gmail.coma bean

Thanks guys, so the responsibility is on the chocolate manufacturer when it is all said and done and the new bean to bar makers will discover in due course that they need to be doing this testing so they can formulate appropriately to the regs if there are any.

So the biggest risk really is then to the hobby chocolate maker who will have absolutely no idea of the heavy metal levels in their beans. I have been making chocolate for almost seven years and have been buying small 1-15kg batches from many origins and have never been given any assurances on heavy metal levels, but then again i have never asked.
Except in the case of the Aussie growers which have soil tested. Oh and i have asked growers from islands that i have made batches for but they dont get testing done but usually these are small plantations.

Speaking from the South American perspective, no individual grower I've ever heard of has the capacity or resources to do this testing.  and its not necessary as they sell mostly to middlemen who in turn sell to aggregators who turn bulk beans into cheap liquor for cheap nestle and winter products. No individual small producer could be held to account under the current value chain.

I assume the big co-ops in San Martin must cooperate with their US and EU clients, either here on site or there at the destination end, testing finished origin products or they couldn't comply with US / EU regs.  The Peruvian Ministry of Agriculture has been concerned about this and actively opposed the latest, stricter EU cadmium regs.

As for Marañon chocolate, we have had our Pure Nacional beans and Fortunato #4 couverture tested in the US and EU and we meet all regs for cadmium content.  We are fortunate that our location in the Marañon Canyon has naturally compliant soils!

Saludos, Brian

Herein lies the importance of effective winnowing - ensuring as much shell as possible is out of the testing stream is helpful in ensuring as much beans as possible pass.

For the hobby / small producer who needs to keep costs down how often would you be required to test for this if your beans are coming from a consistent source?
Thank you to everyone on here for being so generous with their knowledge.


Member Marketplace

Promote TheChocolateLife

Bookmark and Share

Follow Clay on:
Twitter :: @DiscoverChoc
F'Book :: TheChocolateLife
F'Book Group :: LaVidaCocoa :: @DiscoverChoc

© 2014   Created by Clay Gordon.

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service